Different Treatment for Non-Genetic Hypertrophic Cardiomyopathy?

Many HCM patients, perhaps even the majority, are currently unable to identify the specific gene behind their HCM through genetic testing.  Despite this obvious difference, family screening, risk stratification and treatment standards are no different for patients who carry a HCM gene and those who do not have identified gene(s).

A recent article published in Circulation suggests that there ARE differences which should result in different treatment for this subset of patients.

In particular, non-sarcomere positive patients:

  • have a better prognosis, with lower rates of heart failure, sudden death, atrial fibrillation and stroke
  • Have lower incidence of family members affected by the disease
  • Are more likely to have additional medical conditions such as obesity, hypertension and diabetes

The article by Dr. Hugh Watkins, a British HCM and genetic expert, suggests that:

  • the risk to first degree relatives of this type of HCM patient is less than 50% and therefore, there is less need for repeated screening of relatives
  • Hypertension should be treated more aggressively in these patients.

Read more about non-genetic HCM here and more about screening these patients here on HCMBeat.

Crypts Sign of HCM? Study Says No

According to a recently published study by doctors in Copenhagen, Denmark, myocardial crypts (clefts, cracks or fissures in the myocardium) are found in the general population. Therefore, this article concludes that crypts seen on scans of the heart are not necessarily an indicator of HCM and do not warrant further investigation. 

This paper is a departure from a 2012 paper by doctors at Tufts, which concluded that myocardial crypts were associated with HCM, and that they were often found in relatives of HCM patients found to be gene positive for HCM, but lacking the hallmark thickening of the ventricle. 

Here is an example of what the crypts look like on MRI.