Reporting Issue with 50,000 Medtronic Fidelis ICD Leads

According to a story broken by Kaiser Health News this week, due to a reporting waiver granted to Medtronic by the FDA, as many as 50,000 problems with the Medtronic Fidelis lead were not reported to the FDA.  Ordinarily, the FDA uses its MAUDE database to collect reports of adverse events in medical devices.  In these cases, the MAUDE database was circumvented.

Medtronic responded by saying that instead of using MAUDE, they disclosed the issues in summary fashion to the FDA, as well as reporting them to physicians and to the public.

The following stories provide additional details about this controversy:


Minneapolis Star Tribune



One thought on “Reporting Issue with 50,000 Medtronic Fidelis ICD Leads

  1. This story frightens me about the FDA / CDRH. I’d love to hear the FDA’s rationale to grant Medtronic a waiver in reporting device problems. Physicians and patients need to be informed about device failures in order to determine a patient’s risk that the device will fire inappropriately or fail to deliver therapy when needed. The longer devices and especially leads remain implanted, the harder they are to extract.

    What other devices have been granted reporting waivers??? Do we need a Sunshine Act for the FDA?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s